Get updates by e-mail. Free!
Why subscribe?

PYSIH twitter
Follow Us on Twitter

  • Recent comments:

  • Top Commentators

    • Travis
    • KHR
    • Grimston
    • RealityCheck
    • Lisa
    • goatgirl
    • rancidrat
    • Janasmom
    • Mrs Arnett
    • Sky


  • Michael Plumadore

    Michael Plumadore, Murdered Aliahna Lemmon
    To the left there is Michael Plumadore. He’s a real “stand up guy” if you ignore his assault charges and criminal record that stretch from Florida up to North Carolina, but Michael was in Fort Wayne, Indiana turning over a new leaf, and serving as a baby sitter for three young girls while their father slept before his third shift job and their mother worked through a bad Flu.

    You’d let this guy look after three girls all younger than 10 years old, right before Christmas, wouldn’t you? In a trailer park with 15 sex offenders as neighbors, this wouldn’t be a problem with you?

    Well there was a problem, and it started with a brick. No, maybe it was something else that started it but I’ll get back to that brick in a second.

    Aliahna Lemmon This is Aliahna Lemmon, 9 years old, excitable, ADHD suffering, but cute as a button I must say, the sort of girl I’d chide about all of her “boyfriends,” and try very hard not to buy a pony for. Aliahna Lemmon deserved a pony for Christmas. She deserved presents under a Christmas tree, but all she got was a brick.

    Michael Plumadore confessed in his third police interview(because the first two did not add up) to beating this 9 year old to death with a brick. Afterward, he hacked her to pieces with a hack saw, buried some of her and kept much of her in freezers both at his trailer and other places around the park. He wrapped her up like she was dog meat, and the horror of it all was too much for me to really wait before I wrote this all down. A 9 year old was murdered with a brick, her body cut up and spread around, and afterward, this man walked down the road, bought a cigar and smoked it.

    I hope your Christmas was better than this. I’m certain it was.

    FacebookGoogle BookmarksGoogle GmailDiggOrkutRedditShare

    74 Comments »

    Similar Posts:

    74 Responses to “Michael Plumadore”

    1. Absurdist says:

      And still nothing floated about his motive, either.

      • Jason says:

        He chopped this poor girl up and froze the remains. His attempt to get away with this crime as well as his methods compared to others who’ve used similar methods are more than suggestive. I’m guessing what they can prove and what he will confess are all that are available and will probably ever be available.

    2. Mikey says:

      The bad thing about the death penalty is that it isn’t used enough. This piece of garbage should be executed now!!!!

      • Jean says:

        Agreed – but this guy is sly as a fox. By confessing and ultimately pleading guilty to murder, he will avoid the death penalty. Note that he did not say a word about molesting or raping the girl – which I suspect he did, and which was the reason he killed her and dismembered her. His assumption was that removing the head hands and feet would keep police from ID’ing the body long enough for any trace DNA to degrade. Child rape will put the death penalty back on the table – hopefully, the coroner will go the extra mile and look for evidence of rape before they put this poor child to rest.

    3. Jerrie says:

      This SOB has no right to be alive. I am shocked that a mother leaves her three girls with a man that has a record. It is very sad that this baby girls life was taken and in such a horrible fashion. The mother is lucky that she still has the other girls. He could have killed them all. I know the mother will regret this the rest of her life. I saw the grandmother on Nancy Grace talking about how a good family friend he was. I just do not understand why the grandmother was not taking care of the girls. They had been at this monsters house for about a week. Just so sad. My prayers are with the family and little Aliahna may you be in Gods loving arms and RIP.

      • Jean says:

        Consider, however, that the woman moved into a trailer park she knew was “teeming with sex offenders,” and that the man she was caring for was also a sex offender. Her judgment of people was more than a little skewed – Plumadore wasn’t a registered sex offender in Indiana and probably looked a lot better than what she was used to. This should give ANY woman pause if she contemplates shacking up with a man who has a record – what message are you sending YOUR children as to what is or is not “normal?”

      • Somebodywhoknewthefamily says:

        The grandmother is a nut bag who has been instatutionalized herself she lived years with a man knowing what he was doing to children not to mention her own child but did nothing and when confronted all she could say was she was living in denial and her name is Leanne Lemmon not fricken Amber Story what is thios make believe time

    4. Sabrina says:

      I really cannot understand why the mother asked this man to watch her children. My best friend is a guy, and I have known him for almost 15 years. In all them years, I never asked him to watch my children for a week, even when I was sick. It just doesn’t make good common sense to me.

    5. cw says:

      What I want to know is what the hell was the mother of the children thinking? She knew the trailer park was a have for sex offenders, but put her own selfish interests ahead of her own children. Hopefully the State will take her other children away from her, since she is obviously an unfit parent.

      • Tiffany says:

        Mr. Plumadore is NOT a registered sex offender as far as anyone’s been able to find. His record included assault and trespassing.

        • Somebodywhoknewthefamily says:

          Really you feel the need to defend his good name who cares if he was a registered sex offender he fing murdered this child bashed her in the head with a brick cut her up into pieces with a hack saw put her head hands and feet in his freezer next to his tv dinners spread the rest of her around the area then went for a smoke why are you dwelling on wether or not he was a sex offender all the while the other 2 girls sleeping in his house while he did all of this to thier sister. Tiffany get off you high horse and come down to reality not everyone deserves to be defended

          • falkoche says:

            She is not defending him, just stating facts.

            • Lillith says:

              It’s ok, I’m sure he’ll never babysit ANYONE again, unless it’s his boyfriend/ cellmate Bubba.
              Does it really matter if it was on his record or not? records can be expunged and sealed, especially if it’s a first time offense. Even for sexual offenses.
              Shocking, yet true. My first ex husband became my first ex-husband right about the time he admitted to me that he had an expunged record for “statutory rape”. Years later, after he was arrested and went prison for his second “satutory rape” offense I discovered that his previous victim wasn’t a 16 year old girl when he was 21, but rather a 7 year old boy.
              Scary shit, huh?

        • KHR says:

          Assault and tresspassing are no unpaid traffic tickets… and I don’t think I’d even let someone who was so flippant about the laws watch my two kids.
          The number of people who I allow to watch my kids can be counted on my two hands. I’m so strict my SIL isn’t on that list. She made bad choices, I’m glad she’s turning herself around, but she’s not going to be alone with the two most important things in my life.
          Ex-cons are, generally speaking, not the best idea for a babysitter.

    6. Tyler says:

      Is there any information on his criminal record prior to the murder?

      • Jason says:

        I’m going to try to format the report the online criminal report gave me into something a little cleaner and update the story, later this evening.

        • Jason says:

          The report is just ugly. It’s an html page and they used tables to format the info and I honestly found myself making custom css and some divs for it last night. I think the better route might be getting the official forms and/or discussing with the other editors if I should put this info up in a different way.

    7. AussieAngel says:

      I am a long time reader, only posted once before, but I feel compelled to post on this.
      How did this become the mother’s fault?
      She certainly should have been more aware of just who the person watching her children was but why is the father not being hung out to dry for the choice of babysitter as well?

      • Tiffany says:

        Mr. Plumadore isn’t a registered sex offender as far as anyone’s been able to find, his record is mostly trespassing and assault. He was a trusted family friend who helped care for the children’s grandfather. As far as we know there were no indications that he was capable of this, it may have just been that Alianna was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

        • Somebodywhoknewthefamily says:

          Yes grandpa’s prison wife took care of him while he died such a good and trusted friend whom he met in prison while serving time for molesting children. Most guys in prison want to kill child molester but not good ole Mike he instead took real good care of him why you may ask because he was comfortable with it maybe because he himself dabbled here and there but never got caught because oh I don’t know he kills them when he is done.

          • PerfektMa says:

            MP was not in jail with JL — that was Shumaker. Plumadore did have a charge made against him for stalking, harassing, sending sexual pics, comments to a 13 year old while living with said childs father (and possibly stepmother MS ~ who continued to have pics of ‘good friend Mike’ on her fb)

    8. Tiffany says:

      As a resident of Indianapolis and someone who has listened to this story for almost a week, I can’t judge the mother. She was in a tough spot, she was sick, she had three children to take care of and their father was working and she did what a lot of parents would do, she sent the kids to a babysitter so she could get some rest. Did she make a bad choice, yeah, but unless you’ve been in her place, don’t judge her and say she’s an unfit parent..

      The suspect isn’t a registered sex offender, his criminal record includes trespassing and assault, so while he may not have been prime babysitting material, there was nothing the police could have found to point the finger at him, let alone the mother. He was a trusted friend who had helped care for the mother’s ailing father.

      As for the trailer park, yes there were about 15 sex offenders living there but if you don’t have the money to live anywhere else, then you do the best you can.

      I’m not making excuses for the mother, but what I am saying is look at the whole story before you blame the mother.

      • Ivy Mike says:

        Ahem. Tiffany, the mom moved her kids and herself into a park full of sex offenders, a fact which she knew. That, alone, makes her too stupid to live. Oh, but let us not forget the reason she made this absolutely idiotic move…to care for her sick father. Sick is the right word.
        See, folks, Daddy was, himself, a convicted sex offender. He and the killer profiled here knew each other because they had been cellmates. Mommy Retardo also was aware of this, but, as Yahoo! news reported today, a neighbor in the trailer park vouched for the new babysitter. Said neighbor, of course, was a sex offender himself.

        Okay, so the Mother Inferior moves herself, and her 3 children into a trailer with a convicted sex offender, in a trailer park full of them, then leaves the kids in the care of a cellmate of Daddy for a week. Oh, and she knew all of this, according to the news story. Jesus, I’m shocked that the kid lasted the week.

        Sorry, Tiffany, but Mommy Retardest is either a blithering, screaming, drooling moron who should be turned upside down and filled with cement so she doesn’t breed any more, or was (most probably) drunk or stoned or both and didn’t give a shit, in. which. case she should be turned upside down, filled with cement, and dropped into a lake…on Monster Island.

        • Gina says:

          Wow. Didn’t know all that…now I hate the mother as much as you, mike. I hope the rest of the girls are safe away from her. I’ve had the flu and I have six kids. No fun. But I have never needed a fucking nap bad enough to trust the word of a sex offender that my kids will be okay when I wakeup.And are you saying that these babies where there Christmas WEEK!?! WTF? Bless your heart, Aliahna. You deserved so much more

        • falkoche says:

          Wow. I didn’t know all that either. I don’t have kids, but I think if I did I wouldn’t make those choices. It’s so not fair that people like that get to have children.

        • barbarella says:

          To Ivy Mike, armed with that info, it certainly clears things up, and I agree that it was an awful and wrong choice for her to make, and she should hold some responsibility for allowing her kids to be around that. But as to the fact that she moved into a trailer park filled with sex offenders, to me, that doesn’t mean a parent is a bad one (speaking, of course, on that fact alone…not everything else, which I agree, certainly calls into question her fitness as a parent). The reason I say this is that I live in a duplex, and within 5 miles of us, there are 67 registered sex offenders. This is EVERYWHERE. Checking your local sex offender registry can be a terrifying thing. In my city alone, after doing some research awhile back, I found that there is nowhere you can live here that there are not a minimum of 3-10 sex offenders within 1 mile, and usually, it’s more than that. Chances are, in this day and age, having access to the knowledge of where sex offenders are located, there are few places ANYONE could live where there aren’t quite a few sex offenders within your very neighborhood. It’s not that things are “worse these days than they ever were” either…those sex offenders have always been there, just as many of them, it’s just that now we have the ability to see where they’re located. As to everything else, I agree, she certainly isn’t a very fit parent.

          • KHR says:

            I was terrified after checking the sex offenders near us, too, until I decided to do a little research. Of the 14 nearest sex offenders, 8 were convicted of looking at images of underage girls, all of whom were 16 or 17, and another two or three were convicted as 18 year olds of having sex with girls who were 16 or 17, there was one pedophile who committed an act against a child, a guy who got caught in a prostitution sting, and a couple rapists. I know which ones who make me the most nervous, and I stay the hell away, especially with my daughters. You have to look at each case individually and decide.
            That being said, I also understand that sometimes that’s the only place you can afford to live. My last neighborhood was chock-full of convicted sex offenders, gang members, and criminals. I couldn’t get out of there fast enough the moment I could, and until then a guard dog, a weapon, and several locks on every entry point had to suffice.
            BUT, I am EXTREMELY picky about who watches over my kids. I check references for babysitters and daycares, and have watched the cameras of daycares to see what’s going on when the boss isn’t in the room. I’ve refused to leave my daughter with my own SIL because I disapprove of her former behavior and her choice of a mate.
            If this mother was more picky about who she left her child with this might not have happened. She gets no sympathy from me for being sick. I’ve been sicker than hell before and still looked after my kids because I couldn’t find anyone I trusted enough to do it for me. I might not have been the perfect mother on those days- I would turn on Beauty and the Beast so I could sit for ninety minutes and I’ll fully admit to going through the drive-thru of the Golden Arches twice that day because I didn’t feel like fighting with the three-year-old about what she wanted to eat. Even though I had to puke with the bathroom door open so I could hear I did it. No sympathy because she had the flu. There’s no excuse for leaving your child with an ex-con.

    9. Sickened mother in Fort Wayne says:

      According to this article from North Carolina, Plumadore was a registered sex offender when he was there. http://www.goblueridge.net/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14218

    10. Gina says:

      I’m not blaming the mother, but if I’ve said it once, I’ve said it a million times, if you wouldn’t trust someone with your blank publishers clearinghouse check, don’t leave someone much more valuable with them. Completely heartbreaking.

    11. Heartbroken says:

      first of all……Knowing that a trailer park has 15 neighbors who are sex offenders…would you move there with your kids…And would you have your neighbor watch your kids…..I sure as heck wouldn’t…..i agree with Gina… if you wouldn’t trust someone with your blank publishers clearinghouse check, don’t leave someone much more valuable with them…..It just breaks my heart…I know the mom was sick and all but I’ve been sick and yet i watch my kids….

    12. Ivy Mike says:

      Tiffany, shut the fuck up. A little girl is dead because her mother shouldn’t have been caring for a pet rock, let alone a kid.

      • Chicalet says:

        A little girl is dead because this douchebitch decided to kill her. Not her mother, unfit as she may be. Lets give credit where credit is due. She failed as a parent to keep her child safe, and he failed as a decent human being to learn the kindergarten lesson about keeping his filthy hands to himself.

      • Trista says:

        no doubt…don’t evem wanna read anymore comments defending Tarah Souders…sick of it

      • Trista says:

        no doubt…don’t even wanna read anymore comments defending Tarah Souders…sick of it

    13. Ft wayne citizen says:

      This being less than 5 miles from my home. I take offense. It is the mother and the fathers fault. They deserve the death penalty as much as the killer. Who leaves their children to a man that’s not family, that includes bathing her two six year olds. Being from close to this area and living here my whole life we all have children we love running around here. That man does not deserve the death penalty, he deserves to rot in jail as someone’s “wife” for the rest of his life. Any mother that can’t take care of her kids while she has the flu, a “flu” that lasted a week, that’s just ridiculous. Our parents raised up with way worse. This hits home with me. How dare anyone stick up for anyone except Aliahna in this situation. Do not justify for the mother, it is HER responsibility to check on the situation and the person watching her children. This is a tragedy and the only person that should be defended is that child. This is a child with serious problems who needs extra love and you pawn them off on someone when the grandma lives next door? How about you have the creep look after you and leave your kids with someone trustworthy. That mother should have checked up on her children everyday multiple times. How is the Christmas for that little girl? Most of you haven’t experienced like we have as a community. Blame goes to all involved. Think of that poor little girl being beat to death. How dare anybody.

      • Jason says:

        And that’s the way I tried to write it. I worked for a few weeks in the bitter winter in Fort Wayne Indiana. At the time, as young as I was, I saw little “good” about the cold wind that blew straight through me, but the people were nice to me and I got my work done and left. We get better by revealing our wounds and keeping them clean so they can heal. This was not an example of “reasonable” child care. This was not an “excusable event.” There’s a lot of blame to toss around, but can anyone really be prepared for someone to grind their daughter up and freeze them? These two “parents” left their children with someone they apparently didn’t really know. The consequences feel like a sucker punch to the privates of everyone who reads about it and yet, I wonder how this can be a teachable moment.

      • Another Ft Wayne citizen says:

        “That man does not deserve the death penalty, he deserves to rot in jail as someone’s “wife” for the rest of his life.”

        Fine, we’ll have the monthly bill for the cost of this troglodyte’s incarceration directly to you. what was that address again?

        • FYI says:

          Just an FYI…it costs the State more to execute a prisoner then it does to keep them in jail for life. I think they should just chop him up and freeze him.

          • Trista says:

            ahh!!never mind that,smear his lower extremities with honey,and tie him to a tree in bear country!!!that would be awesome,I’m sure the bear would think so,but I live in Canada I don’t know if there’s bear country in Indiana!!

        • KHR says:

          Taken from the Death Penalty Information Center:
          “Total cost of Indiana’s death penalty is 38% greater than the total cost of life without parole sentences”

    14. Tiffany says:

      Just to let everyone know this is the original Tiffany and not that blooming idiot that defended mommy dearest!!

      I feel so sorry for the surviving children. I’m sure they will have some sort of survivor remorse or whatever it’s called. Those are the real victims in this case not the mother,father,suspect or any of the other pedos in the trailer park. Lord, please comfort the two other little girls and make sure Satan makes Mikey-poo his personal girlfriend!! Amen!!

    15. deb says:

      OMG…. It’s like Zahra Baker all over again. God only knows what that little girl had gone through in her short little life. The way things go, we’ll most likely never know the full story. Was this a case where a creep-ass just went off JUST THIS ONE TIME and killed a little girl, or had other things happened to her in the past, and this was the time that he went too far and had to kill her?

      It makes me want to cry when I think of that poor little disabled girl, trying to live the best she could, probably trying to behave the best she could, being beaten to death with a brick and then cut into pieces like she was nothing. I have no qualms at all about blaming every single adult who had any part in that little girl’s life and failed her so miserably. They all deserve to rot in hell. I raised three kids, each a year apart, nursing them through all the childhood illnesses, having the flu or whatever virus came along myself…. and I NEVER once hurt one of them and they are all very much alive, as are my five grandchildren.

    16. The Bosses Secretary says:

      In twenty-five years of raising children, I never sent the kids to live with anyone else for a week but their own father or my mother, no matter how sick I was, except for a two week stint in the hospital, when they stayed with their dad. And I was sick plenty; when you have little kids you catch all the crap they have, and you have it for weeks.

      A week away from home with some guy? How sick were you? The only way that should have happened is if she was sick enough to be hospitalized.

      In theory, you should be able to leave your young children with a good friend. But hell, even my good friends wouldn’t take all my kids in for a week. Why chance it?

      • KHR says:

        I’ve been sick enough that I threw up in my favorite purse because it was close and I didn’t want to wake up my daughter, who fell asleep across my lap. My neighbor stopped by with my mail, and offered to watch her. She was the sweetest old lady with about five thousand grandkids, but I still refused. Five thousand grandkids meant a lot of random people in and out of her house, and I didn’t want my daughter over there. I was like that for four days until my husband got out of work half a state away and came home for his two days off.

    17. Wendy says:

      did you notice that the photo of the little girl was taken at a funeral?

      • Somebodywhoknewthefamily says:

        The picture is from her child molesting grandfathers funeral he died december 3, 2011 probably the most recent photo of Ali

    18. Somebodywhoknewthefamily says:

      This was not the first time Tarah left her children with “family friends” Hell she left them with her father who was a child molester convicted right so I know because I helped convict him. There are so many holes in Tarahs story about where they are from where they have lived why they lived where for one her mother going on Nancy Grace calling herself Amber Story does she think she is a porn star her name is leeanne Lemmon married to James Lemmon while running a daycare from thier home turned a blind eye to what he was doing to the children in thier care dramaticly commiting herself being suicidal when the children began to speak out. Fleeing to Iowa to avoid prosicution. When confronted Tarah herself could not deny her father had molested her makes me wonder if maybe her father really fathered Ali as well. Ali did suffer many disabilities that could easily be explained by insest Tarah was still a child when she became pregnant yet non of that mattered to her as she repeatedly left the girls with thier child molester grandfather and his cell mate buddy Mike. That is not exactly how I would chose my close trusted family friends. So which was it did they move to that trailor park because they couldn’t afford anywhere else or was it to be close to ailing father. James Lemmon didn’t deserve to be cared for he ruined childrens lives boys and girls destroyed families severed friendships from his actions. I think it is tragic what happend to that little girl and more so tragic the 2 sexual assaults she had to endure while living in Iowa. I work 3rd shift and I am a single mother who just so happend to be recovering from the flu I only missed one day of work and have had my children by my side everyday I grab my sleep where I can and above all put my children and thier needs above my own. Tarah has no business raising children she is damaged beyond repair. She should be charged with neglect she should have the other children taken from her then her and her husband can sleep all day and do whatever they want and noone gets hurt. The whole family is sick and I am sickend by the fact that as a result of all of this I guarentee that they are gonna bank big time with all of the well gooders who want to help and when its time for the lifetime movie and all the talk show interviews that poor little girls death just became thier golden ticket and that pisses me off.

      • PerfektMa says:

        Thank you for insight into the horrors of this family. RIP Ali baby ~ you were too good for where you were place my angel!

      • Declare says:

        Somebodywhoknewthefamily…please tell us more. I believe what you are saying and there is just something NOT right about the whole story from the family. How is Plumadore connected to the family? There is no record that he was in prison with Tarah’s “father”, but the story of how they met as given by the sex offender Shumaker, just does not add up. Was Tarah “selling her girls” to these perverts? Are drugs part of the picture?

      • Lisa says:

        Another local here. 15 miles north. I don’t believe Aliahna was fathered by egg donors child molesting father. If you have seen pics of the bio-dad, she looks like his clone. He doesn’t even physically look like a man, HE looks more like Aliahna because he looks like a girl. Anyhow…he’s a piece of shit too. Had to ask his town for donations for money to get to the Fort. He has no licence and no job and no car. His ex-wifes ( not TS) brother is one of the guys who molested Aliahna in Iowa. He has/had Mike on his FB page, and he has/had his own childs molester ( his BIL) as a friend on FB also. Everyone I have read about involved in this little girls life are worthless pieces of shit…EVERY SINGLE PERSON!! This was a small park with 24 trailers and 15 of them were occupied by sex offenders. This piece of shit mother knew this and EVEN asked her piece of shit, child molesting dad if her kids would be safe there. He said yes, duhhhh, what would she expect him to say. I don’t know anyone, not one single person in my life that sent their kids away when they were sick. Her piece of shit husband needed his fucking sleep, and also had no problem sending all 3 of those girls to a 40 yr old single mans (criminal) house for a week. Why couldn’t he have lost some sleep like all normal people do who work 3rd shift why situations arise. All 3 of those girls were old enough to be home and basically take care of them selves to a point of making a sandwich for lunch and quietly playing in their rooms. This mother is totally responsible for her daughter being dead, and her step-father and g-ma too. She had 3 different kids with 3 different men, all worthless. The other ex has a rap sheet a mile long, and has been caught with child pornography on his pc. She also had all of Aliahnas things removed from their home 3 days after she found out her daughter was slaughtered like a pig, or worse. She also took all the memorial things people had left and did who knows what with it…probably got thrown away. She couldn’t bear to look at anything of Aliahnas things but she could live 2 doors away from the murder scene. I could go on and on about these worthless MF’ers, but I don’t have all night…but I’m sure you all get the picture now. I can honestly say I’m glad Aliahna is where she is now, in the arms of God. She will NEVER know pain again in her life. I hate the way it happened, and I hope when the final autopsy results are in, it will show that the first blow with the brick killed her, then we can all know she didn’t suffer in horrible pain. I pray to God for those results.

        • Jes says:

          Wow, thanks for the insight. It sounds like this poor little girl barely had a chance in life. It’s so heartbreaking and tragic that so many kids live like this, in the midst of so many sick and twisted (or even just uncaring, apathetic, selfish) adults. My mother was never so sick that she would leave us in the care of a strange man in a rough neighborhood. Kids would be better off alone in the house than with a sex offender! Sadly, most of us don’t know our own neighbors could be going through this until it’s too late. Walls can hide so much evil.

    19. SanDiegoAnne says:

      I’m also a single mother. This month alone, I’ve had two surgeries, one infection caused by the last surgery, and a stomach virus. Though I’ve been sick for most of the month, not once did it cross my mind to leave my son with anybody – and I’ve friends who had offered to help. I purposely didn’t take the pain pills given to me so I would be alert enough to take care of my six year old son. In fact I never leave him with anybody except his before/after school program and of course his school. I don’t leave him with a babysitter while I see my friends, or sleep, or do anything. I’ve gotten into arguments with friends over me never being able to go “go out” with them because I just refuse to leave him. And I don’t regret or resent any of it. There was absolutely no excuse for these parents to ditch their children, which is exactly what they did. I hope there are charges brought towards them for this, and if not that at the very least, it haunts them formthemrest of their lives. But sadly, I’m sure it probably won’t.

    20. virign says:

      i blame the parents because it was their job to keep this little angel safe and they failed! miserably! at the expense of this child really! who allows ANY man to babysit their daughters? they are lucky only one was killed they could of all been killed!! while mommy nursed her “flu”, more likely a hangover! these people should need a license to bear children!!

    21. virign says:

      i blame the parents because it was their job to keep this little angel safe and they failed! miserably! at the expense of this child really! who allows ANY man to babysit their daughters? they are lucky only one was killed they could of all been killed!! while mommy nursed her “flu”, more likely a hangover! these people should need a license to bear children!!

      • Erin says:

        So you are saying no man can be trusted to babysit? Every person born with a penis will violate and/or murder any child he is entrusted with? I am all for being careful with who you leave your children with, but a sweeping generalization like that is paranoid and offensive.

    22. Erin says:

      This is horrifying to me because I live like 10 minutes from where this happened. It’s all we talked about at Christmas. I kept looking at my little girl and I couldn’t help but question how someone could not only kill an innocent child, but find it fun to hack her up?? It’s so f*cking disgusting.

      People around here really do give Indiana-ans a bad name. So many parents are drunk, on meth, making meth, and they just dump their kids off wherever someone will have them. It scares me to death that sh*t like this can happen in my back yard. My daughter will not be leaving my sight until she’s 30!

    23. Lonnie Wolf says:

      https://www.facebook.com/#!/groups/359405277407944/

      Thanks Lonnie Wolf! Folks, apparently this here is a facebook group that is trying to figure out who Plumadore really is.
      –Jason

      • Lisa says:

        Heres another link. This one will keep you reading for days on end. You should find the oldest post and work you’re way up for a time-line.

        http://www.facebook.com/justiceforAliahnaLemmon

        • Wondering says:

          Disgusted by the violence. Evil manifests itself in many ways. We all know by now that MP is evil incarnate, but I an convinced that some of the nastiness being spewed all over the internet is just as evil. Oh wait a minute I must be mistaken, it’s being called justice by those spewing the hate.

          Everyone is angry about what happened to that little girl. Her family failed her and her siblings, the system that should of put that animal behind bars failed her. The only thing that can be done now is to wait for the investigation to be completed and let the judicial system do its job.

          Watch your children, do not leave them with anyone you are not 100% positive of. If you think a child is being abused in any way report it. Also when you are on the internet posting, stop and think, Is this something I want my child to see? Is this the way I speak in front of my child? If it is then in my opinion you are not the type of person I would want around my child.

    24. Sickened Neighbor says:

      http://ottumwacourier.com/local/x191084568/More-local-ties-to-slain-Indiana-girl

      Here is a little bit more about this scumbag. That monster lived across the street from me when he lived in Iowa. That was the summer my kids weren’t allowed to play in the front yard because he gave me the creeps long before he killed that poor little girl.

    25. kae says:

      and my Mom gets irritated with me because its taking me weeks to find a house because with each one I find I use 3 other websites to check each different type of offender & crimes that have happened. apparently for her my daughters safety doesnt matter that much which is why they dont stay with her anymore.
      This just breaks my heart.

    26. Jasmine says:

      Lonnie wolf is a family member of michael. Disgusting! Trying to profit your a sick fuck this whole family is sick! No one wants to join your group with your fake profile /reported to Allen county sheriffs department & Facebook.

      • Lonnie Wolf says:

        Jasmine, Who told you I was a family member? Thats how rumors start. Do you want me to tell them about you…mmmm? Now go wash that goo of your face, it’s dinner time!

    27. Bri says:

      I am writing an essay about this sad story for school. I want to know the urge that made Plumadore do this to a beautiful 9 year old? Who in their right mind does this? She had her whole life ahead of her! One thing we do know is she is with God in heaven laughing and having fun with the other children now.

    28. Jes says:

      I know people want to defend the mother, and it’s my first instinct to pity her, too, but I just can’t imagine letting a grown man I barely know, who is not a relative, watch my 2 daughters. I don’t have a single woman in my family who trusts her young children alone with some random guy from the neighborhood. I have to wonder if she wasn’t doing drugs or something because that would explain her apathy about the pervert-ridden place she’d moved to.
      Also, I would not take care of my father if he was a child molester…he made his evil choices in life, so why should I endanger my kids by having them live with him? Molesters make friends with other molesters – not a good environment for children. The sex offender registry is so easy to check.

    29. Brian says:

      Plumadore should get the Chair! Another sicko that preys on children. What kind of animal would treat a child this way? He is like Ricky Smyrnes! … Wesley Spectrum Ricky Smyrnes & Alcoholic Nita M. saw autistic kids as “retards” .. Nita let Ricky beat up Autistic children while attending this horrible school, while Nita let him do what ever he wanted and he turned out a killer. Sobering news for Nita?

    30. Lillith says:

      Poor baby. This would be a horrible way to die! This bastard should be beaten *almost* to death with a brick, dismembered with a hacksaw (starting with his fingers and toes), and his body parts fed to starving dogs. Justice is served.
      RIP Aliahna Lemmon. Maybe one day Heaven will have enough angels, and sicko bastards like this will die before they can hurt anyone. Condolences to her family, even her pedo- loving sorry excuse for a mother. Please consider sterilization as an option…

    31. LLt says:

      On May 11th, 2012,Plumadore pleaded guilty to murder and abuse of a corpse and will be sentenced on June 18th to life in prison without parole.The prosecution was going to seek the death penalty.

    32. hearing aids batteries says:

      She created bad options, I’m grateful she is switching herself around, but she is not going to be alone with the two most significant elements in my lifestyle.

    33. Molly says:

      Sentenced to life.

      Turns out that the grandpa that mom had moved back to take care of was also a convicted child molester. At first I reserved judgement for the mother, because I thought she was just doing what was in the best interest of her family, but not only did she move her kids into a pit of pedos, she was moving there to take care of one.

    Leave a Reply